News:

9/8/05: 6 months, 75,000 posts! Thanks to Nishi for the post!

Main Menu

Wireless Router

Started by Alice, April 16, 2007, 11:33:59 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Alice

Anyone know where to get a decent wireless router that's on the fairly inexpensive side? 

Really, at most I'll probably be 15 feet away from the router when I'm using it.  If even that.

Gamplayerx

I don't, but I can say that the people who work the telephones at Linksys are very nice when you completely screw up your router on a Sunday night. 

Bennyhana

Quote from: Alice on April 16, 2007, 11:33:59 AM
Anyone know where to get a decent wireless router that's on the fairly inexpensive side? 

Really, at most I'll probably be 15 feet away from the router when I'm using it.  If even that.

Cable is cheap.

Jessie

I need to get one too, so if you find a cheap one, let me know.
we should have kept the quote pyramid up to rape Jessie in the face.

Beefy

Decent does not usually equal in expensive.

When I set mine up, it cost, with cable, a bit over a hundred if memory serves.

Distance from router is only part of the issue.  Protecting your wireless from other network leeches is also important, lest they steal your bandwidth.

Alice

Quote from: Bennyhana on April 16, 2007, 11:45:58 AM
Quote from: Alice on April 16, 2007, 11:33:59 AM
Anyone know where to get a decent wireless router that's on the fairly inexpensive side? 

Really, at most I'll probably be 15 feet away from the router when I'm using it.  If even that.

Cable is cheap.
Having a dog with a gimpy leg that gets caught up in cable and pulls your computer off of things, causing them to fall to the floor and break - is not cheap.  I need wireless.

nallen

#6


25 ft. range, $3.92, run it along the wall or under the carpet to avoid dog-leg issues

http://www.monoprice.com/products/product.asp?c_id=102&cp_id=10208&cs_id=1020801&p_id=140&seq=1&format=2&style=
May the Magic Plastic bless you and keep you.

Alice


Jessie

we should have kept the quote pyramid up to rape Jessie in the face.

Gamplayerx

Quote from: Jessie on April 16, 2007, 12:07:56 PM
I think this is the model that was recommended to me, for $50

http://www.buy.com/prod/linksys-wireless-g-broadband-router-wrt54g/q/loc/101/10336386.html
That's what I have.  And if you jack it all up on a random Sunday night, the nice Indian man will fix it for you.

Jessie

For the record, I don't need wireless at all, but I really like kicking back in my bed and watching tv while chatting/writing/surfing.  It's nice!  When I have some extra cash, I'll get a wireless router.
we should have kept the quote pyramid up to rape Jessie in the face.

nallen

Does your laptop have a 802.11b/g card?  I guessing it does.   Go with g if you're tired of shitty performance (I was skeptical until I switched my router out, it's a huge difference is signal strength and reliability.)   Ignore n and draft-n, it's unnecessary.

Linksys gets a lot of flak for folks, but the truth is they have known weaknesses (none of which apply to you), and lots of support. 

~$50

http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/SearchTools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=628108&CatId=373


A bit cheaper, but more prone to issues of interoperability:

~$30

http://www.tigerdirect.com/applications/SearchTools/item-details.asp?EdpNo=578283&NoMapp=1
May the Magic Plastic bless you and keep you.

Alice


nallen

Quote from: Alice on April 16, 2007, 12:22:31 PM
What's b/g?

802.11b vs 802.11g 

They are different wireless specs, b gives a transfer rate of ~10Mbits/sec, whereas g gives 54 Mbits/sec, is actual data speed this is about 8 kb/s for b and 43.2 kb/s for g.   Reality is you'll get closer to 5 for b and probably 30 for g.  That's at a good signal strength level, if there are problems, expect b to drop to ~1-2kb/s and g to 10 kb/s.   The difference here is big, since the b gives noticeable lag on web surfing, while the g will not.

May the Magic Plastic bless you and keep you.

Bennyhana

Quote from: nallen on April 16, 2007, 12:34:10 PM
Quote from: Alice on April 16, 2007, 12:22:31 PM
What's b/g?

802.11b vs 802.11g 

They are different wireless specs, b gives a transfer rate of ~10Mbits/sec, whereas g gives 54 Mbits/sec, is actual data speed this is about 8 kb/s for b and 43.2 kb/s for g.   Reality is you'll get closer to 5 for b and probably 30 for g.  That's at a good signal strength level, if there are problems, expect b to drop to ~1-2kb/s and g to 10 kb/s.   The difference here is big, since the b gives noticeable lag on web surfing, while the g will not.



However, you want a router that is backwards compatible to b, because there are some pieces of hardware (streaming music devices, etc.) that only do b. 

Bishamonten

Do what the rest of do.

Hire chinese kids to memorize binary and run the back and forth between your laptop and your cable modem.

Bennyhana

Quote from: Bishamonten on April 16, 2007, 12:50:49 PM
Do what the rest of do.

Hire chinese kids to memorize binary and run the back and forth between your laptop and your cable modem.

But then, for the love of God, hide your coke.

Bishamonten

Quote from: Bennyhana on April 16, 2007, 12:53:19 PM
Quote from: Bishamonten on April 16, 2007, 12:50:49 PM
Do what the rest of do.

Hire chinese kids to memorize binary and run the back and forth between your laptop and your cable modem.

But then, for the love of God, hide your coke.

If you pay them in coke, they work longer and faster.

meredith

#18
I'd agree with the suggestions for linksys models in the $50 range.




Quote from: nallen on April 16, 2007, 12:34:10 PM
802.11b vs 802.11g 

They are different wireless specs, b gives a transfer rate of ~10Mbits/sec, whereas g gives 54 Mbits/sec, is actual data speed this is about 8 kb/s for b and 43.2 kb/s for g.   Reality is you'll get closer to 5 for b and probably 30 for g.  That's at a good signal strength level, if there are problems, expect b to drop to ~1-2kb/s and g to 10 kb/s.   The difference here is big, since the b gives noticeable lag on web surfing, while the g will not.



who the hell is this guy?

also -

802.11b - full speed  1.2 megabytes/sec
802.11a/g - full speed  6.7 megabytes/sec

802.11b is totally adequate for setting up mom or grandma.  It's not an issue of lag though, just bandwidth.  If you are in a dense apartment area with many wireless networks, you are going to see performance issues, which is probably where nate's experience is coming from.  There are 12 channels available for wireless networks but they overlap so you can only have 3 or 4 networks in the same airspace before you start crowding other signals out.

nallen

Here's a handy dandy table, stolen from Wikipedia of course  (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.11):

Protocol    Release Date        Data Rate (Typ)    Data Rate (Max)    Range (Indoor)    Range (Outdoor)
802.11a    1999                      25 Mb/s                     54 Mb/s                     ~25 meters     ~75 meters
802.11b    1999                        5.5 Mb/s                     11 Mb/s                 ~35 meters    ~100 meters
802.11g    2003                     25 Mb/s                     54 Mb/s                ~25 meters             ~75 meters
802.11n    2007                   200 Mb/s                   540 Mb/s               ~50 meters          ~126 meters


It's important to know that the numbers are given in bits (b), not bytes(B), it take 8 bits to make one byte.  The rate is almost an order of magnitude less, 5.5 Mb/s = 0.68 MB/s, and 25 Mb = 3.125 MB/s
May the Magic Plastic bless you and keep you.

BigDun

Another important thing to keep in mind is that 802.11b and 802.11g operate in the 2.4 Ghz spectrum. This is the same radio frequency that most portable phones use. Also, microwave ovens can often interfere with this spectrum.

802.11a is faster than 802.11b (even though it is lower in the alphabet) and works on the less crowded 5.4 Ghz frequency.

If your laptops supports it, and the price isn't too much, I would recommend going with the 802.11a if you are in an apartment building. Otherwise go with 802.11g and hope that you don't lose connection when you make some popcorn or are talking on a call with a portable phone.
16:26:25 [DownSouth] I'm in a monkey rutt

Alice

How do I know if my laptop supports it?

swolt

Get two tin caps. Put a string on one and tie it to the cable modem. Put a string on the other one and tie it to the PC.

make sure the cans are facing each other.
A clever man commits no minor blunders.

swolt

Quote from: Alice on April 16, 2007, 02:51:26 PM
How do I know if my laptop supports it?

what is the make/model of your laptop? Anything made in the past 2 years should support both B and G
A clever man commits no minor blunders.

Alice


ReBurn

I bought my router from Newegg.com. They usually have awesome rebates on wireless gear. Mine's a D-Link and it's been awesome, but a lot of people don't like them.
11:42:24 [Gamplayerx] I keep getting knocked up.
11:42:28 [Gamplayerx] Er. OUT!

swolt

Dell's site says you have a 1420 wireless, which supports both B and G
A clever man commits no minor blunders.

Alice

Quote from: swolt on April 16, 2007, 03:15:49 PM
Dell's site says you have a 1420 wireless, which supports both B and G
Thanks!

I know jack about hardware stuff.

swolt

I have had problems with D-Link and do not recommend them.

The router Jessie linked is the one I like. As Gamp said Linksys has great tech support. You might pay a few extra bucks but in the long run I think it's worth it.
A clever man commits no minor blunders.

ReBurn

Quote from: swolt on April 16, 2007, 03:16:37 PM
I have had problems with D-Link and do not recommend them.

The router Jessie linked is the one I like. As Gamp said Linksys has great tech support. You might pay a few extra bucks but in the long run I think it's worth it.
You're probably right. D-Link isn't exactly the easiest to configure. I've always had bad luck with Linksys. Seems like any brand you go it's a crap shoot.
11:42:24 [Gamplayerx] I keep getting knocked up.
11:42:28 [Gamplayerx] Er. OUT!

Jessie

Since I'm getting a new desktop, and I have two working laptops (thanks to swolt and Carroll), I'm thinking that I need to break down and get a wireless router. 

Does this look like a decent deal?

http://www.stootsi.com/store/item.aspx?item=68060600

I don't ever use the printers that I have, so it may actually be more than I need.

I know next to nothing about networking.  Will I be able to set up a network myself?
we should have kept the quote pyramid up to rape Jessie in the face.

Bennyhana

Quote from: Jessie on January 07, 2008, 11:18:27 AM
Since I'm getting a new desktop, and I have two working laptops (thanks to swolt and Carroll), I'm thinking that I need to break down and get a wireless router. 

Does this look like a decent deal?

http://www.stootsi.com/store/item.aspx?item=68060600

I don't ever use the printers that I have, so it may actually be more than I need.

I know next to nothing about networking.  Will I be able to set up a network myself?

It doesn't look like that's actually a wireless router.  It looks like that just hooks up printers and computers via ethernet to your existing wireless network.  I could be wrong. 

swolt

that isn't a router, just a hub.

wireless networking is pretty easy, you should be able to do it yourself.
A clever man commits no minor blunders.

Jessie

Quote from: Bennyhana on January 07, 2008, 11:21:40 AM
Quote from: Jessie on January 07, 2008, 11:18:27 AM
Since I'm getting a new desktop, and I have two working laptops (thanks to swolt and Carroll), I'm thinking that I need to break down and get a wireless router. 

Does this look like a decent deal?

http://www.stootsi.com/store/item.aspx?item=68060600

I don't ever use the printers that I have, so it may actually be more than I need.

I know next to nothing about networking.  Will I be able to set up a network myself?

It doesn't look like that's actually a wireless router.  It looks like that just hooks up printers and computers via ethernet to your existing wireless network.  I could be wrong. 
I thought that's what this meant:

Connect multiple PCs: This server makes it possible to connect a cluster of computers, easily and cost-effectively. You can connect up to four PCs to your wireless network without adding any new adapters.
we should have kept the quote pyramid up to rape Jessie in the face.

Bennyhana

Quote from: Jessie on January 07, 2008, 11:22:30 AM
Quote from: Bennyhana on January 07, 2008, 11:21:40 AM
Quote from: Jessie on January 07, 2008, 11:18:27 AM
Since I'm getting a new desktop, and I have two working laptops (thanks to swolt and Carroll), I'm thinking that I need to break down and get a wireless router. 

Does this look like a decent deal?

http://www.stootsi.com/store/item.aspx?item=68060600

I don't ever use the printers that I have, so it may actually be more than I need.

I know next to nothing about networking.  Will I be able to set up a network myself?

It doesn't look like that's actually a wireless router.  It looks like that just hooks up printers and computers via ethernet to your existing wireless network.  I could be wrong. 
I thought that's what this meant:

Connect multiple PCs: This server makes it possible to connect a cluster of computers, easily and cost-effectively. You can connect up to four PCs to your wireless network without adding any new adapters.

I think that means that you can physically plug 4 computers into it, and they'll be connected to your existing wireless network.

Jessie

Oh.  Eff a bunch of that.  I have two insane cats and a hyper 11 year old boy in my house.  The last thing I need is more wires running everywhere.
we should have kept the quote pyramid up to rape Jessie in the face.

meredith

Linksys WRT54G has seen plenty of testing and abuse and is still recommended, though I did just have one new from Amazon completely die after 2 weeks. :P

Youph just got a Belkin Wireless-G router from Best Buy that seems to be working well, and after my Linksys died, I ran to Best Buy and found the Dynex Wireless-G router in a separate aisle.  Dynex's wireless parts are all the same as Belkin's - This router had a different piece of plastic on top, Dynex instead of Belkin branding, and a price tag $10 cheaper.

Jessie

I'm buying an old used Linksys from Amazon for $10.  If it works well enough for me to sit on my bed and talk on AIM, that's good enough for me.
we should have kept the quote pyramid up to rape Jessie in the face.

DownSouth

For 10 dollars and a warm poptart you can yell at me anywhere in the house and I'll type what you say.
16:15:43 [Gamplayerx] Juneau, I could really go for some pie. You better Belize it!

Jessie

Quote from: DownSouth on January 07, 2008, 02:18:12 PM
For 10 dollars and a warm poptart you can yell at me anywhere in the house and I'll type what you say.

What can I get for $5 and a toaster strudel?
we should have kept the quote pyramid up to rape Jessie in the face.

DownSouth

Quote from: Jessie on January 07, 2008, 02:24:17 PM
Quote from: DownSouth on January 07, 2008, 02:18:12 PM
For 10 dollars and a warm poptart you can yell at me anywhere in the house and I'll type what you say.

What can I get for $5 and a toaster strudel?
Catchr speak and I get to crap in the bushes.
16:15:43 [Gamplayerx] Juneau, I could really go for some pie. You better Belize it!

Alice

Quote from: DownSouth on January 07, 2008, 02:33:32 PM
Quote from: Jessie on January 07, 2008, 02:24:17 PM
Quote from: DownSouth on January 07, 2008, 02:18:12 PM
For 10 dollars and a warm poptart you can yell at me anywhere in the house and I'll type what you say.

What can I get for $5 and a toaster strudel?
Catchr speak and I get to crap in the bushes.
Bwahahaha!

Jessie

I just successfully set up my first wireless network.  Go me!  It's secure and everything.
we should have kept the quote pyramid up to rape Jessie in the face.

BigDun

16:26:25 [DownSouth] I'm in a monkey rutt

Gamplayerx

Quote from: BigDun on January 11, 2008, 10:23:44 PM
I could hack it.
Yeah, right.  Sure you could.  You couldn't even get mine to work, nevermind hacking anything.  You hack. 


;)